Commodity Focus -
Tantalum
When
Apple Inc. recently launched its
newest retail store in Washington D.C., the grand opening drew not
just eager shoppers, but angry protestors. The protest highlighted
the growing concern among consumers and regulators that the tantalum,
tin, tungsten and gold, the so-called ‘conflict minerals’ found
in many electronics, are helping to finance militia groups
responsible for horrific violence and deaths in Central Africa.
Of these
4 minerals, tantalum is in the
position of being of the greatest concern due to the fact that in the
last 10 years ever increasing amounts of conflict tantalum has
entered the western world, while recently there have also been
significant shutdowns of western tantalum producers.
The sale
of tantalum concentrate (also
known as coltan) originating from the Democratic Republic of Congo
(DRC) has continued to grow as it is produced at the very lowest cost
– that of child and forced labor. The United Nations Group of
Experts report on conflict tantalum production in the DRC refers to
this extraction method as “mining by military motivation” –
that is, people with guns at the top of the hole watching children
digging for minerals in the hole.
Over the
last 10 years, the amount of
tantalum and tantalum products that are from feed stock originating
in the DRC has increased to be up to approximately 50% of all the
tantalum being used in the western world. It is highly unlikely that
there is any electronic OEM that has not been the recipient of
conflict tantalum.
And if
you happen to see a photograph
of a Congolese boy or girl of perhaps 10 years of age smiling for the
camera, as they are digging for tantalum, they are smiling because
they are alive – as opposed to the approximately 5 million of their
countrymen who have died over the last 15 years in this extraction
process and related violence. Make no mistake: this is the single
greatest loss of life since the Second World War and is the reason
that there are more United Nations troops mobilized in the DRC than
in any other jurisdiction globally.
In terms
of conflict-free tantalum
production, there should arguably have been a tantalum price increase
sometime in 2008, due to the normal operation of supply and demand.
Although overall economic conditions were not robust in 2008, it was
the continued and ‘cheap’ conflict production of tantalum that
subverted the normal operation of these market forces.
In
late 2008, Australia’s Talison Minerals shut down its Wodgina mine,
formerly the world’s top tantalum producer at two million pounds
per annum. Talison’s move was followed by the closure of Cabot
Corporation’s Tanco mine in Canada (175,000 pounds per annum) in
early 2009.
To
exacerbate this supply problem, the United States Defense Logistics
Agency – which provided up to 500,000 pounds annually - exhausted
its tantalum stocks between 2001 and 2007 and suspended sales in
2008.
Industry
initiatives to address the use
of conflict minerals has been minimal, creating an explosive
environment within the industry as governments and interest groups
have been forced to weigh in. And they have.
On
July 15, 2010, US President Barrack Obama signed the Wall Street
Reform and Consumer Protection Act which included an amendment which
is directed to curtail the importation of minerals such as tantalum
from areas of conflict. The amendment demands US-based or listed
companies to be transparent about the origins of certain minerals in
their products. This amendment is a “game changer” as this will
affect many major electronics companies operating in the western
world.
“Support
has quickly mounted in the
US and internationally for an accountability system similar
to the Kimberley Process for
diamonds that would strive to eliminate the trade of minerals
originating in conflict areas and prevent sales from funding
violence. The OECD [Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
Development] is also making progress in this direction,” says Ron
MacDonald, a former Canadian MP who advises resource companies on
regulatory issues through his consulting company Cansource Inc.
“They’ve already come up with a fairly detailed draft of
recommendations and we should expect to see new guidelines from the
OECD by the end of the year.”
The
recent developments in the market
are starting to have a significant effect on the supply chain of
tantalum raw materials. For example, a recent transaction was at a
30% premium to the historic tantalum price and this was paid to one
of the very few conflict-free tantalum producers, Brazil’s
Companhia Industrial Fluminense.
The head
of marketing for Talison
Minerals, Bryan Ellis, told Reuters recently that he expects demand
to recover to 2007 levels of about 6 million pounds per annum and for
prices to climb in step with increasing demand from the electronics
industry for historic tantalum products. In addition, new
technologies will contribute to its growth including a significant
number of new tantalum applications that could be grouped under the
‘green energy’ umbrella.
Tantalum
has several characteristics
that make it virtually irreplaceable in most applications - new and
old – including the highest ‘capacitance’; i.e., the ability to
hold and release instantaneously the most electricity per gram.
In terms
of current market conditions,
notwithstanding the most gloomy prognostications about an impending
‘double dip’ for the US economy, it is very clear that the demand
for high-end electronics is very robust. For example, the new iPhone
and iPad are products whose design and manufacture are dependant upon
the use of tantalum.
Other
potential producers include Commerce Resources Corp. (TSXv: CCE) and
Gippsland Ltd. (ASX: GIP) who are developing deposits of tantalum in
Canada and Egypt respectively. The development of additional sources
of tantalum raw materials could have a significant positive effect on
the marketplace.
Commerce
Resources is aiming to become an alternative supplier through its
100%-owned Blue River tantalum-niobium project in central British
Columbia, Canada. AMEC is conducting a preliminary economic
assessment on the deposit expected to be released by the fall of
2010. Australian explorer Gippsland Ltd. is seeking financing for
the development of its Abu Dabbab project within the Central-Eastern
Desert in Egypt.
The
obvious benefits of new producers of conflict-free tantalum would be
the long-term stability that alternate sources would bring to the
marketplace. Makers of electronic components such as capacitors
would have fewer worries of a future price spike in the market and
there would be no viable reason to source tantalum from a conflict
region where the ‘cost’ should not ever discount the value of
human life.
|